Strategy

Marketing Agency RFP: Template, Timeline and Scoring Guide

A marketing agency RFP template with the 10 sections to include, a realistic timeline, how many agencies to invite and a weighted scorecard for responses.

By Abby Di NiroPublished Last updated

Quick Answer

A marketing agency RFP (request for proposal) is a written brief that asks a shortlist of agencies to explain how they would reach your goals, who would do the work and what it would cost, all in the same format. A good RFP states your goals, scope, budget range, timeline and the scoring weights you will use.

Most companies only hire a marketing agency every few years, so the process gets rebuilt from scratch each time. Someone finds an old template, adds a list of questions, sends it to whoever came up in a search, and three weeks later the team is comparing five proposals that answer different questions at different prices. A good request for proposal fixes that before it starts.

RFPs are not going away. In the Agency Management Institute's 2024 Agency Edge study of 400 marketing decision makers at organizations with under $500 million in revenue, one in two had issued an RFP or RFI to find an agency, and 91% said it had been at least somewhat effective. Yet only 18% said they assess agencies with an established scorecard (Agency Management Institute, Getting Hired in 2024). The brief gets written. The scoring is usually left to gut feel.

This guide gives you both: a copyable marketing agency RFP template with the ten sections that matter, a realistic timeline, and the marketFX Brief, Compare, Choose Method™ for turning responses into a decision you can defend. If you are earlier in the process, start with our 12 questions to ask a digital marketing agency.

What Is a Marketing Agency RFP?

A marketing agency RFP is a document you send to a shortlist of agencies that describes your business, your goals and the work you need, and asks each agency to respond with an approach, a team and a price in a set format. Its job is to make proposals comparable, so you judge agencies on the same brief instead of on who tells the best story.

An RFP is one of three related documents. Many searches combine them, so it helps to know which one you need.

RFI vs RFP vs RFQ for hiring a marketing agency
DocumentWhat it asks forWhen to use itTypical length
RFI (request for information)Capabilities, team size, experience, clients, basic feesYou have a long list and need to cut it to three to five agenciesA few pages and 10 to 15 questions
RFP (request for proposal)A proposed approach, named team, plan for the first 90 days, pricing and measurementYou have a shortlist and a defined scope or goal8 to 15 pages plus attachments
RFQ (request for quotation)A price for a fixed, clearly specified deliverableThe work is already defined, such as a set number of ads or a site build to specA specification and a price table

When Should You Use an RFP to Hire a Marketing Agency?

Use an RFP when the engagement is large enough that a wrong choice would cost you months, when several people need to agree on the decision, or when your company's purchasing rules require competitive bids. Skip the formal RFP when the scope is small, when you already know the agency you want, or when the real problem is still unclear.

Signs an RFP is worth the effort:

  • The work covers several channels or teams, such as paid media, SEO, content and reporting, and you need one plan across them.
  • Procurement, finance or leadership will review the decision and want a documented process.
  • You are replacing an incumbent agency and need a fair comparison that includes them.
  • You plan to keep the relationship for years, so the cost of a bad fit is high.

Signs a lighter process is better:

  • The project is a one-off with a fixed deliverable. An RFQ or a short brief is enough.
  • You do not yet know what is wrong with your marketing. An audit or a diagnostic project will tell you what to ask for.
  • You run a small business and are choosing between two or three agencies you already know. A one-page brief and a call with each will usually get you further.

What Should a Marketing Agency RFP Include?

A marketing agency RFP should include ten sections: company background, business goals and KPIs, scope and exclusions, your current setup, budget range, timeline, questions for agencies, proposal format and pricing table, evaluation criteria, and terms and contacts. The table below shows what each one is for and what to ask agencies to send back.

The 10 sections of a marketing agency RFP
#SectionWhat you writeWhat agencies send back
1Company backgroundWhat you sell, to whom, where, and how you make moneyEvidence they understood it, in their own words
2Business goals and KPIsRevenue, leads, bookings or margin targets, with current baselinesHow their plan connects to those numbers
3Scope and exclusionsChannels, markets and tasks in scope, and what is notConfirmation of scope, plus anything they think is missing
4Current setupYour internal team, other agencies and partners, tools and dataHow they would work alongside your people and partners
5Budget rangeAgency fees and media spend as separate rangesA plan that fits the range, with options above and below it
6TimelineKey dates from questions to start dateA realistic onboarding plan for the first 90 days
7Questions for agencies8 to 12 questions that matter for your decisionDirect answers, in order, within a word limit
8Proposal format and pricing tablePage limits, file format and a pricing table to completeProposals and prices in the same structure
9Evaluation criteriaThe criteria and weights you will score againstResponses aimed at what you actually value
10Terms and contactsConfidentiality, ownership, deadlines and one contactQuestions sent to one person by one date

1. Company background

Write one page, not ten. Cover what you sell, who buys it, where you operate, how customers find you today and what makes a good customer worth to you. Agencies cannot propose a sensible plan without knowing your margins and sales cycle, even roughly.

2. Business goals and KPIs

State goals as business outcomes with a baseline and a target: qualified leads per month, booked appointments, online revenue, cost per acquisition, or customer lifetime value. "Increase brand awareness" is not a goal an agency can be held to. "Grow qualified leads from 120 to 180 a month at or below today's cost per lead" is.

3. Scope and exclusions

List the channels and tasks in scope, such as paid search, paid social, SEO, AI search visibility, email, content, website changes or reporting. Then list what is out of scope. Exclusions prevent the most common problem in agency proposals: two agencies quoting different amounts of work and looking like a cheap option and an expensive one.

4. Your current setup

Describe who does what today. Name the internal roles, the other agencies and freelancers you work with and plan to keep, and the main tools you use for analytics, ads, CRM and your website. Most businesses already have people and partners in place, and the new agency has to fit around them. Asking how an agency would work with your existing team and partners tells you more about the working relationship than any credentials page.

5. Budget range

Share a range. Agencies cannot design a sensible plan for an unknown budget, and a blind ask produces proposals you cannot compare. Separate agency fees from media spend, because a proposal that blends them makes it hard to see what you are paying for. Our guide to how much a marketing agency costs in 2026 explains the cost layers that sit behind a quote.

6. Timeline

Give dates for questions, answers, proposals, finalist meetings, the decision and the start date. Leave enough time for good answers. A deadline of a week or two pushes agencies toward reused material.

7. Questions for agencies

Ask 8 to 12 questions, each tied to something you will score. Good RFP questions ask for evidence and specifics: who will work on the account and what share of their time, how the agency would approach your first 90 days, how it measures results against your goals, and what it would change or stop doing. Set a word limit, such as 250 to 400 words per answer, so responses stay focused.

8. Proposal format and pricing table

Tell agencies exactly how to respond: page limit, file format, section order and the pricing table they must complete. A shared pricing table is the single most useful part of an RFP, because it lets you compare like with like. The template below includes one.

9. Evaluation criteria and weights

Publish the criteria and the weights. Agencies will focus on what you say matters, and your own team will score more consistently if the weights were agreed before anyone read a proposal.

10. Terms and contacts

Cover confidentiality, who owns any work produced during the process, the submission deadline and one named contact for all questions. If you will share answers to one agency's questions with all agencies, say so.

Copyable Marketing Agency RFP Template

Copy the outline below into a document and fill in each part. Delete anything that does not apply. Most strong RFPs end up between 8 and 15 pages before attachments.

Marketing agency RFP template outline
SectionPrompts to complete
Cover pageCompany name, project name, issue date, response deadline, contact name and email
1. About usWhat we sell; who our customers are; where we operate; how customers find and buy from us today; what a good customer is worth
2. What we want to achieveTwo to four business goals with today's baseline and a 12 month target; how we measure them today
3. Scope of workIn scope: channels, markets, deliverables. Out of scope: what stays in house or with other partners
4. How we work todayInternal team and roles; other agencies and freelancers we are keeping; tools for analytics, ads, CRM, website and reporting; who has admin access to each account
5. BudgetAgency fee range per month or per year; media budget range; any one-off budget for setup, tracking or website work
6. TimelineQuestions due; answers shared; proposals due; finalist meetings; decision; start date
7. Questions8 to 12 numbered questions, each with a word limit
8. Proposal formatPage limit; section order; named team with roles and time on the account; plan for the first 90 days; reporting sample; completed pricing table
9. How we will decideCriteria, weights and scoring scale; who is on the selection team; whether finalists will present
10. TermsConfidentiality; ownership of submitted work; no unpaid speculative creative unless stated; how questions are handled

Attach anything that saves agencies from guessing: a recent performance summary, a list of current campaigns and channels, brand guidelines, and any reporting your leadership already uses.

The marketFX Brief, Compare, Choose Method™

The marketFX Brief, Compare, Choose Method™ is the three-stage process we recommend for running an agency RFP. Brief is writing a document that agencies can actually answer. Compare is scoring every response against the same criteria before anyone talks about price. Choose is testing the finalists in conversation and agreeing terms before you sign.

The marketFX Brief, Compare, Choose Method: three stages for running a marketing agency RFP. Brief: goals with baselines, scope and exclusions, your team and partners, budget range and published weights. Compare: score every response 1 to 5 against the same weighted criteria, then compare prices in one table. Choose: finalist working sessions, reference calls, and a contract with clear ownership and exit terms.

The marketFX Brief, Compare, Choose Method™
StageQuestion it answersMain outputCommon mistake it prevents
BriefCan an agency answer this without guessing?A 10-section RFP with goals, budget range and weightsProposals that answer different questions
CompareWhich responses best meet the brief?A weighted scorecard and a single pricing tableChoosing on presentation style or lowest headline price
ChooseWill this team work well with ours?Finalist sessions, references and an agreed contractA good proposal followed by a poor working relationship

How Long Does a Marketing Agency RFP Process Take?

Most marketing agency searches take two to three months from first brief to decision. In the Agency Edge study, 47% of clients expected a search for a new agency to take two to three months, 15% expected one month or less, and 24% expected four to six months (Agency Management Institute, Getting Hired in 2024).

Bar chart of how long clients expect a search for a new marketing agency to take, from the Agency Management Institute 2024 Agency Edge study of 400 marketing decision makers. One month or less: 15%. Two to three months: 47%. Four to six months: 24%. Seven to nine months: 9%. Ten months to a year: 4%. More than a year: 1%.

A realistic plan for a mid-sized search looks like this. Shorter is possible when the scope is small. Longer is common when several stakeholders or a procurement team are involved.

Example timeline for a marketing agency RFP (about 10 weeks)
WeekStepOwner
1 to 2Agree goals, scope, budget range and weights internally; write the RFPYou
2Send an RFI or make calls to cut a long list to three to five agenciesYou
3Issue the RFPYou
4Agencies send questions; you share answers with all of themBoth
6Proposals dueAgencies
7Score proposals independently, then agree scores as a groupYou
8Finalist working sessions with two or three agenciesBoth
9Reference calls and contract termsYou
10Decision, notify every agency, plan onboardingYou

How Many Agencies Should Receive Your RFP?

Send your RFP to three to five agencies. Fewer than three gives you little to compare. More than five creates more reading than most teams can score carefully, and it lowers the effort strong agencies are willing to put in, because their odds of winning drop.

Pitches are expensive for both sides. Digiday reported that the Association of National Advertisers estimated in 2023 that running a pitch costs clients more than $400,000 on average and costs each participating agency more than $200,000, figures that reflect large advertiser reviews (Digiday, October 24, 2025). Your process will cost far less, but the principle holds: every extra agency adds hours of reading, meetings and scoring for your team.

Use an RFI or a short call to build the shortlist. Look for agencies that have worked on problems like yours, that can name the people who would do the work, and that ask good questions before they pitch.

How Should You Score Marketing Agency RFP Responses?

Score every response against the same weighted criteria, with each reviewer scoring alone before the group compares notes. Use a 1 to 5 scale, multiply by the weight, and only look at price once the quality scores are in. This stops the cheapest or most polished proposal from setting the anchor.

Example weighted scorecard for RFP responses (illustrative weights, adjust to your priorities)
CriterionWeightWhat a 5 looks like
Understanding of the business and goals20%Plays back your goals accurately, asks sharp questions and spots gaps in the brief
Strategy and first 90 days20%A clear plan with priorities, and a view on what to stop doing as well as start
Team and fit with your people and partners15%Named people, time on the account, and a clear way of working with your team and other agencies
Relevant experience and proof15%Similar problems solved, with starting points and outcomes you can check with references
Measurement and reporting15%Reporting tied to your business goals, with a sample report
Commercial clarity15%Completed pricing table, clear inclusions and exclusions, sensible terms

When you compare price, use the pricing table, not the headline number. A low retainer that excludes setup, tracking, reporting or creative is not cheaper if you have to pay for those separately later.

Pricing table to include in your RFP (every agency completes the same rows)
Line itemAgency feeBilling modelIncluded or extra
One-off setup, audit and tracking$Fixed or hourly
Monthly strategy and account management$Retainer
Paid media management, by channel$Flat, % of spend or hybrid
SEO, content and AI search visibility$Retainer or project
Creative production$Per asset or included
Reporting and analytics$Included or separate
Tools and software passed through$At cost or marked up

What Are the Most Common Marketing Agency RFP Mistakes?

The most common RFP mistakes are hiding the budget, asking for too much free work, sending the RFP to too many agencies and choosing on presentation rather than on the brief. Each one makes responses harder to compare or pushes the best agencies away.

  • No budget range. Agencies guess, and you get proposals at very different scales.
  • Goals without baselines. Without today's numbers, nobody can propose a realistic target.
  • Asking for unpaid speculative creative. It rewards agencies with spare capacity, not the best fit. If you want to see thinking, ask for a short working session on a real problem instead.
  • Too many questions. Fifty questions get fifty short, generic answers. Ten good ones get real thinking.
  • Leaving out your existing team and partners. The new agency has to work with them, so the RFP should say who they are.
  • Scoring after the pitch meeting. Score the written responses first, then use finalist meetings to test the top scores.
  • Silence after the decision. Tell every agency the outcome and offer brief feedback. Your next search will be easier for it.

Both sides feel these problems. In research reported by Digiday, 68% of brand marketers and 84% of agency executives surveyed by Creativebrief said the pitch process was not fit for purpose (Digiday, October 24, 2025).

Should You Write an RFP or Start With an Audit?

If you are not sure what is wrong with your current marketing, start with an audit before you write an RFP. An RFP asks agencies to propose a solution. If the problem is unclear, every agency will diagnose it differently, and you will be comparing guesses.

An outside review of your accounts, tracking and results gives you the baselines, priorities and scope that a good RFP needs. Our marketing audit services page explains what that review covers.

How marketFX Can Help Before You Write Your RFP

marketFX is a North American omnichannel marketing company that helps businesses bring their internal teams, agency partners and channels together so time and budget go where they matter most. If you are about to run an agency search, we can give you an outside view first with a free audit: a one-page written summary of what we find, plus a 30-minute walkthrough. It is yours to keep, whether you include us in your RFP or not.

FAQs

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an RFP in marketing?
An RFP, or request for proposal, is a document a company sends to several marketing agencies asking each to propose an approach, a team and a price for the same brief. It is used to compare agencies fairly before hiring one.
How do I write an RFP for a marketing agency?
Start with your goals and baselines, then describe your business, scope and exclusions, current team and partners, budget range and timeline. Add 8 to 12 questions, a required proposal format with a pricing table, and the weighted criteria you will use to score responses.
How many agencies should I send a marketing RFP to?
Three to five agencies is enough for a meaningful comparison. Use an RFI or short calls to cut a longer list down first. More than five usually means rushed scoring and less effort from the strongest agencies.
Should I include my budget in a marketing agency RFP?
Yes. Share a range, with agency fees and media spend shown separately. Without a range, agencies have to guess, and the proposals you receive will be built for very different budgets and will be hard to compare.
How long should a marketing agency RFP process take?
Plan for about two to three months from writing the brief to choosing an agency. In the Agency Management Institute's 2024 study, 47% of clients expected an agency search to take two to three months. Smaller searches can move faster.
What is the difference between an RFI and an RFP?
An RFI asks for general information about an agency's capabilities and experience and is used to build a shortlist. An RFP asks the shortlisted agencies for a specific proposal, team and price for your project.
Do small businesses need an RFP to hire a marketing agency?
Usually not a formal one. A one-page brief with your goals, budget range and timeline, sent to two or three agencies, followed by a call with each, gives most small businesses what they need. Use the same scorecard to compare them.

Writing an Agency RFP? Get an Outside View First.

Start with a free audit: a one-page written summary of what we find in your marketing, plus a 30-minute walkthrough. It is yours to keep, and it gives your RFP real baselines.